Andy Burnham’s decision to cut business rates for pubs, clubs and live music venues by 20 per cent has divided Independent readers, with many agreeing with Tom Kerridge that the saving is too small to make a real difference against soaring costs.

The new prime minister unveiled the policy this week as part of a wider push to ease the cost of living, promising nearly 32,000 hospitality businesses would benefit by an average of £1,100 a year.

But several readers pointed out that figure barely dents rising VAT, energy bills and business rates that have climbed steeply in recent years, with one comparing the gap to little more than a gesture.

Others were more positive, welcoming the move as a genuine lifeline for pubs at risk of closing, while some questioned whether Burnham’s flurry of early announcements amounts to serious policy or a bid to build trust after a bruising path to Downing Street.

Here’s what you had to say:

This will just keep them on life support

For many pubs, this will just keep them on life support for a while longer. Taking into account the increase in business rates last year and the NI changes their tax burden is still much higher. A welcome move, but doesn’t reverse the damage done.

Langley

This could save pubs

The plan to cut 20 per cent off business rates for pubs and a variety of clubs is a very welcome move and may well prevent them from being compelled to close their doors permanently. Removing the VAT element of cost from electricity will be helpful for everyone, especially those of us who are really struggling to make ends meet.

It really does seem that Andy Burnham is already starting to address some of the many issues that require urgent attention in this country. His pledge to end homelessness has been well received too and it would be wonderful if this plan can be achieved in the fullness of time. Andy Burnham may well have worked his way up the ranks as a ‘career politician’ which is the chosen path of them all, it seems to me, but he’s already striving to make a positive difference to the population of this country.

JanetC

Pubs provide a service beyond just alcohol

Good news. Locals are like community centres and welcome to most, book reading coffee drinkers, birthday celebrations, quiet pint and a bet, meeting up with friends, live music lovers, sport followers, general get-togethers and if they’ve got a beer garden, it’s a nice day, take a day off through the week and head over, feeling smug doesn’t cover it.

Get a free fractional share worth up to £100.
Capital at risk.

Terms and conditions apply.

Go to website

ADVERTISEMENT

Keep Pubs Open, they provide a service, somewhere to go if you need to forget stuff for a couple of hours or just need to be around people and it doesn’t have to mean alcohol.

leafspot

The customer won’t feel it

Nice gesture, but it won’t be passed to the customer, and it’s a 4 per cent cut in taxes – 20 per cent of 20 per cent that is – but at £7 a pint, and it literally being cheaper to drink out in Spain, Italy, Portugal, than it is to have a beer in your house in the UK, I will continue to order my beers from Amazon, and continue to spend all of my money abroad when I go on holiday to get the value from the labour I put in to get the money in the first place, we rarely go out in the UK because of the prices, it’s just not worth it, apart from Wetherspoons, sometimes.

Nicko

This is not good economics

This is not good economics. Pubs and hospitality businesses are low-productivity businesses. Continually giving them tax breaks preserves inefficient firms instead of encouraging investment and labour to move into more productive areas of the economy. For long-term growth, subsidies are not the answer. And it’s hard to believe these tax cuts will be paid for entirely by taxing vape shops and the like. More probably, the cost will fall on taxpayers or add to government borrowing. Not good.

Musil

Why demonise vape shops but not alcohol?

Whilst I am a big fan of pubs, clubs and bars, this demonising of vape shops is wrong and harmful. Proper, specialist vape shops have helped hundreds of thousands of people quit smoking and hugely benefited their communities. Alcohol is the most harmful drug in the country, leading to poor health, obesity, homelessness and violence, yet Labour’s message is that alcohol makes a huge contribution to the community while nicotine vapes, which reduce smoking, are a scourge. I’m connected to a specialist vape shop and have helped thousands of people quit – the answer is to licence shops and root out the dodgy sellers, not punish everyone.

AntAgain

Small gifts won’t build trust

It’s not at all surprising that people are sceptical about Burnham’s sprinkling of small gifts. Seems it’s going to be a little like an advent calendar for his first week – let’s see what token is in the box each day. He’s going to have to live with the lack of trust generated by his strategy for getting himself into the PM job. People judge you on what you do, not what you say – Burnham and allies like Streeting, Healey, Mahmood, Rayner et al have shown us their (lack of) character through a year of disloyal backstabbing. It is what it is and trust builds slowly. People are now looking for something deeper in terms of principled and strategic leadership for real growth and change. PR laden small gift giving isn’t going to cut it.

Pondering

Burnham is on the side of working people

As well as Burnham being on the side of working people, he’s also pro-business – Tom Kerridge’s business will still be £1,100 better off with this cut than without it, a bonus Starmer was never going to deliver. When Burnham was campaigning in Makerfield he was asking voters to trust a politics that’s often disappointed them. A PM has a choice whether to earn that trust through what they deliver, and Burnham has chosen to help with the cost of living, however small a step. Don’t knock the small stuff – it’s the small stuff that matters most to people, and hopefully there’ll be bigger stuff to come.

Amy

Some of the comments have been edited for this article for brevity and clarity.

Want to share your views? Simply click ‘log in’ or ‘register’ in the top right corner to sign in or sign up. Once registered, you can comment on the day’s top stories for a chance to have your opinions showcased.

Want your voice to stand out? Independent Premium subscribers enjoy priority for featured comments. Subscribe here.

Make sure you adhere to our community guidelines, which can be found here. For a full guide on how to comment, click here.

By Thursday, Burnham’s attention had turned to businesses, announcing a 20% cut to rates for pubs and small live music venues.

Aidan Lavin co-owns the Raven and Bine pub in Southampton and said: “It’s a promising start from the new prime minister, however, I fear it’s nothing even close to enough.

“The increasing pressure from VAT to business rates to an increased minimum wage, it just feels like the walls are closing in from all angles.”

Lavin said he believes that without further measures, businesses across the South would not survive.

“It’s coming to a point now where we are going to lose some of our inns and taverns, never to be returned,” he told the BBC.

On Friday, Burnham headed to Manchester to spend his first day working at No 10 North, a new regional branch of the PM’s office.

It is part of a move to shift power away from Whitehall and in to “every postcode”, external.

Operating from Heron House in Manchester’s city centre, No 10 North will be the government’s new situation room for growth, it was announced.

It brings the “levers of local economic growth and devolution together under one roof for the first time”, said the government.

“There’s an assumption that grandparents just babysit.

“My mum’s 82 and my dad’s 87 with quite advanced dementia, so it’s not as simple as sending the boys up to them for a couple of hours.”

Harriet thinks thought needs to be given to the way the school year is structured.

“Six weeks is a long period, especially for SEND children, because of the lack of routine. It makes it really difficult,” she said,

The Somerset Parent Carer Forum surveyed its members, and said it was a “recurring concern” that there is a struggle to find holiday activities.

“Too often, activities aren’t able to provide the support children need, or parents have to stay throughout, meaning they don’t receive the respite they desperately need,” said CEO Ruth Hobbs.

“School holidays should be a time for children to have fun and build friendships, while families have the opportunity to work or recharge.

“Single parents are one of my biggest worries at this period, as they don’t get a break,” she added.

Hobbs advised checking local authority websites, external, which publish lists of activities for SEND children, and social media.

She also said activities can get booked up far in advance, so recommended calling early to secure a spot.